If it’s time to replace that old, tired roof, you probably have a lot of questions. Not the least of which is this…
What kind of materials should I use?
Because with more choices than ever before, that decision can feel a bit overwhelming.
However, with some simple, common-sense guidance, you can make the perfect choice for your home—and get a roof that fits your budget, looks great, and is built to keep your home safe and dry for decades to come.
So give the following guide a scan. By the end, you’ll have a much better idea of which roofing type will work best for you. Then, be sure to give Smucker Exteriors a call for your free quote.
And now, without further adieu, here are the main considerations for both metal and asphalt shingle roofing for Pennsylvania homeowners.
What Are the Basic Differences Between Metal and Asphalt Shingle Roofing?
When it comes to replacing your roof here in good ol’ PA, two products reign supreme: asphalt shingles and standing seam metal.
Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material in our area—and for good reason.
Asphalt shingles are:
- Affordable
- Easy to install
- Available in a wide variety of colors
Metal roofing, while not quite as wide-spread, is another fantastic option for all home types.
Metal roofs are:
- Energy efficient
- Exceptionally durable
- Long-lasting and nearly maintenance-free
Since both are such fantastic products, let’s break this down a bit further.
What is the Minimum Slope for Metal vs Asphalt Shingle Roofing?
Depending on your roof slope, the choice between metal vs shingle roofing may be quite simple. Simply put, shingles require a slightly steeper slope to ensure they don’t take on water.
- Metal roofs can be installed at slopes of .5:12 (half an inch of vertical rise to each foot of horizontal run)
- Asphalt shingles require a slope of 2:12 (two inches vertical rise to each foot horizontal run)
If you have questions, it’s best to get an assessment from a trusted roofer in your area.
What Are the Lifespans of Metal vs Shingle Roofing?
If long-term durability is a priority for you, metal roofing may be the clear choice.
Here’s why:
- Asphalt shingles usually last around 20-30 years (depending on brand and proper installation)
- Metal roofs can easily last 40-70 years, sometimes longer
If you’re planning to stay in your home for the long-haul, the upfront costs of metal may be worth it. However, a quicker turnaround may mean asphalt shingles will work fine for you and your home.
Speaking of which…
What is the Difference in Cost Between an Asphalt Shingle Roof and a Metal Roof?
Here’s the breakdown between asphalt shingles and metal roofing installation costs:
- Asphalt Shingles: $5–$8 per square foot installed
- Metal Roofing: $9–$14 per square foot installed
While upfront costs are the determining factor for many homeowners, consider the long-term. Metal often requires fewer repairs and lasts twice as long—which can make it a more affordable choice over time.
Energy Efficiency: Metal vs Asphalt Shingle Roofing in Hot and Cold Climates
Generally speaking, metal roofs are more energy efficient than asphalt shingles in both hot and cold climates.
Here’s why:
- Metal reflects solar heat (rather than absorbing it like asphalt) and keeps your home cooler in the summer
- Metal is less susceptible to damages from freeze-thaw cycles and sheds ice and snow more easily—meaning fewer repairs over time
How Do Asphalt Shingles and Metal Roofs Compare in Terms of Maintenance?
Asphalt shingles are more likely to need spot repairs over time—things like replacing cracked or missing tabs after a storm. They can also be prone to moss or algae growth in shady areas.
By contrast, Metal roofing is virtually maintenance-free. And while not entirely immune to issues—like rust on cheap panels or damage from improper installation—you’ll generally spend less time worrying about your roof if you choose metal.
Can I Install Solar Panels on Either Shingle or Metal Roofs?
Yes. Both roofing types are excellent for installing solar panels.
That said, metal may even come out ahead. Due to an increased lifespan, a metal roof will almost certainly outlive your solar panels—eliminating the need for having to remove them during a roof replacement or repair.
Which is the Most Eco-Friendly Roofing Material?
When comparing metal and asphalt shingle roofs, metal comes out as the more eco-friendly.
Here’s why:
Most metal roofs are made entirely from recycled materials—and can be recycled again at the end of their service life. Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, often end up in landfills, and also require petroleum (a fossil fuel) to produce.
The Bottom Line: What Should I Consider When Choosing Between a Metal or Asphalt Shingle Roof?
Choosing the proper roofing materials for your next roof replacement is a big decision. And the truth is, there’s no one size fits all.
When making the choice for your home, consider the following:
- Budget: Asphalt shingles cost nearly half the price of a new metal roof. However, if you plan to stay in your home—and can afford the upfront investment—metal may be more cost-effective over time
- Curb Appeal: What is the style of your home and neighborhood? Shingles offer a warm, classic look, while metal roofs lean toward a modern or farmhouse/agricultural feel
- Talk to the Experts: If you’re still undecided, a reputable roofer can help you make the right choice—especially if you choose specialty Amish roofing in Lancaster County (if you don’t mind us saying so)
Ready for a New Roof? Get Your Free Quote from Smucker Exteriors Today
Here at Smucker Exteriors, we know how important your new roof is.
It’s your first line of defense against the elements. And, along with your siding, it’s the main factor in keeping your home safe, dry, and looking great for decades to come.
So if you’re in Lancaster, Chester, or Berks County and are ready to explore your options, reach out today for a free quote. The Smucker team has been keeping Pennsylvania homeowners safe and dry for over 20 years—and we’re ready to do the same for you.
So give us a call and see why we’re one of the most trusted roofing companies in Lancaster County.
