From saving money on botched jobs to avoiding a nightmare contracting experience, choosing the right team to install your home’s exterior upgrades matters.
Therefore, we’re continuing with Part 2 of our Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Right Exterior Contractor (start with Part 1 here). Give these tips a quick read and then be sure to reach out and put us through the wringer.
We look forward to hearing from you and helping to keep your home safe, dry, and comfortable for decades to come.
Now let’s get on with the tips.
Tip #6. Consider the Hidden Costs
The fact is, some projects—and contractors—may be budget-restrictive. But before you go with the lowest quote, consider the following.
Your home’s exterior is the most important element for protecting the interior, foundation, and framing from very serious (and expensive) water and pest damage. Saving a few hundred dollars (or even thousands) may feel good at the moment, but the wrong cuts can cost you tremendously down the line.
Before going with the low-ballers, consider the fact that lower bids might mean:
- Lower quality materials
- Less experienced labor
- Missing details in work scope (and price bumps halfway through)
- Cut corners or shoddy craftsmanship
That being said, more expensive doesn’t always mean better. The key is agreeing on a fair price for clearly defined work from a contractor you trust. And when that work comes backed by a Lifetime Workmanship Warranty and manufacturers’ warranties that cover you for decades, you’re in good hands.
Tip #7: Get Everything (Yes, Everything) in Writing
The reality of construction is that vague contracts create problems. This goes for both the homeowner and the contractor.
For example, without a clearly defined project scope or materials, an unlucky homeowner may find themselves on the hook for something they didn’t originally bargain for. On the contractor's side, unfair homeowner complaints can be fielded by referring back to written documentation.
That said, be sure your proposal outlines the following before you sign on the dotted line:
- The scope of work to be completed
- Materials being used
- Estimate timeline
- Total cost
- Payment schedule
- Warranty information
Doing so ensures you’re both protected, and everyone ends the project happy!

Tip #8: Pay Attention to Communication
Early communication patterns are one of the biggest predictors of how your project will go. Why? Because it isn’t whether or not there will be problems during your renovations (most large-scale renovations run into something), but instead how those issues are handled and communicated about along the way.
From your first communications, ask yourself:
- Were my phone calls and emails responded to promptly?
- Do they answer questions clearly?
- Are sales reps patient in explaining the work and technicals to me?
- Do they seem organized and prepared?
These points are important. Exterior projects often involve scheduling issues, weather delays, material deliveries (both on time and otherwise), and coordination between crews.
A contractor who values communication will make the process far less stressful for everyone involved—homeowner, crews, and vendors alike.
Tip #9: Trust Your Gut
While this may be a bit less scientifically rigorous, your instincts matter.
If something feels off during the estimate process—be it pressure tactics, unclear answers, or a lack of professionalism—it’s usually worth backing away.
A good contractor should make you feel confident and informed, not rushed or confused. Especially when there are so many reputable contractors you can work with…
Which leads us nicely to our final tip.

Tip #10: Should You Hire an Amish Contractor?
Here in Lancaster, Chester, and Berks counties, the Amish contractors have a reputation to uphold—particularly in the home construction space.
But just because the Amish are known for high-quality products, that doesn’t necessarily mean you should forego all of the previous nine points.
What’s important is making sure a traditional work ethic, attention to detail, and culture of integrity and stewardship are married to all of the more practical points you’ve learned in this guide.
The Right Contractor Makes Everything Better!
The Smucker Exterior crews know how important your home is. It’s where you and your loved ones live. As such, it needs to be kept safe, dry, and comfortable for everyone inside.
After more than 25 years, our crew is still excited to help Pennsylvania homeowners protect their investments and families. And to us, there’s nothing better than the look on a customer’s face after seeing their home transformed.
If you’re in Lancaster, Chester, or Berks County, we’d love to meet you at your home for a detailed assessment of your property and dreams.
Should you decide to work with us, your project comes backed by the assurances of hand-picked crews trained beyond best practices, the installation of top-tier materials with leading manufacturers’ warranties, and a commitment to exceeding industry standards of craftsmanship…
Plus a Lifetime Workmanship Warranty on all of your exterior home renovations.
Give us a call with your Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Right Exterior Contractor handy. We’d be happy for you to put us through the paces.

Smucker Exteriors knows how important your home is. Our crews have been keeping Pennsylvania homeowners comfortable, safe, and dry for over 25 years. With all exterior remodels and installations backed by a Lifetime Workmanship Warranty and the assurance that comes from highly-skilled crews and reputable products, there’s no reason to wait on getting your free quote in Lancaster, Chester, or Berks counties today!











